VCDQuality Forums (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/index.php)
- DVDR (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?forumid=24)
-- Secret Window *NTSC* - DVDRIP - Centropy (http://www.vcdhq.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=41250)

Secret Window *NTSC* - DVDRIP - Centropy

After watching this, I am not sure what to think. The NFO says untouched video and keeps all the audio tracks. The movie is only 3.4 gigs with all the language tracks (2x 5.1 and 1x 2.0) on it. So assuming this really is untouched video, I give:

Video 10/10 - Compared to the retail, this is 1:1. Can't improve on video over the retail/untouched.

DVD-R 7/10 - I would have kept a featurette or two instead of some of the trailers I've seen 100 times already and the useless 2.0 English and 5.1 French tracks... That is approx 850 megs of useless data. Getting lazy.

Now for my review of the "untouched" video. I watched this movie without even looking at the VOBs. While watching, I found the video pretty blurry and crappy. Within 10 mins I turned on the info to check the bitrates and we're in the high 2s low 4s on average. For a retail untouched video this is pretty shitty for a 97 min movie. After watching the whole movie, I looked at the Secret Window trailer (included on the DVD) and it was 10x better picture quality than the actual movie. If I paid for this, I would be pissed. But the video is bad for untouched. However, if it really is untouched, then Centropy couldn't have done anything to improve it, but out of curiosity I will rent it to see if the movie VOBs are really that small, especially since there are only approx 1.5-2 gigs of extras missing (couple featurettes and a few trailers).

I have a small feeling the movie was downsampled. I can't prove it until I can rent it, but it is just a hunch. Only thing that would make sense is if the fullscreen version is on the disc also and not mentioned that it was ripped in the NFO. Without the French and 2.0 english, this release would be probably an even 3gigs.

quote:

---

but out of curiosity I will rent it to see if the movie VOBs are really that small

---

__________________


Jeremy Clarkson: 'So, you won one championship, but Schumacher has now won three. Who's better?'

Damon Hill: 'Me'

Jeremy Clarkson:: (laugh)

Damon Hill: 'When he wins a championship at 37 years old with four kids, a 25 year old team mate and is being barged off the track by someone in their 20's with no concept of danger, I'll believe he's at least equal to me!'

quote:

---

Originally posted by DigitalAngel
Wow..theres dedication for you

All seemed fine to me as "Mr-Joe-Bloggs-DVD-downloader-&-watcher"

Wanted see this, missed it at cinema, vid didnt seem blury to me at all, but I didnt watch the trailer to compare and audio was 5.1, say no more really! Dodgy imaginary guy in big hats lolol

9/10/7

---

my copy burned fine..

overall on quality its fine..

9/10/8 movie is looking good even at 4.4g

__________________
Reality Is Only A State Of Mind...