Air1
Jan 2003
In the Cockpit
|
quote: Originally posted by gibber9583
Jesus christ.....4 posts and no one has really said anything about the release yet.....
anyways....The video looks pretty good even with the lower bitrate. The source must look really clean.
Audio: Very good audio throughout...This is the type of movie that would benefit from DTS. But the DD mix in this movie is quite good.
Movie: Great flick...
8/9/9
I agree on the previous posts to yours having nothing to do with the release.
The video, I agree, too, is great despite lower bitrate and anyone expecting a better release is just dreaming. Unless, of course, a DVD9 release.
The audio -- Again I agree it's great. I also agree and wish the world I could have seen DTS on this release but I understand with the bitrate and all. I mean, to those who don't know, DTS tracks can take 4-6 times the space on a release that DD5.1 does. One of the last re-endocdes I did had a DD5.1 track that was around 200 MB while the DTS track was over 1 GB, for example.
Movie - Again I agree. VERY great film. I may buy it, if not just for DTS.
I disagree, though, on your 8/9/9 rating.
I would say:
9.5 (considering what they had to work with and do in downsampling, and in comparison to other such releases by other groups) for Video.
10 for Audio (You can't blame them for no DTS, really. Come on, now.
8.5 for movie in my opinion so we're not too far off here.
9.5/10/8.5
I probably will buy this, actually.
Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged
|